You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
From far inland...The last time I saw lobster being prepared on tele, the chef did just what you're doing here. The guy with him said, "Wait. What? Why didn't you just toss him in the pot of boiling water?"The dude was the fisherman who pulled the lobster with his pots. So...in your experience, do most people nowadays do this before putting in the pot? I was always told they die instantly anyway (again, I'm talking crawdaddies which are fresh-water, mini lobsters-ish).Curious!
Well, it's the Mister who does all the cooking and he says that boiling them may be a little crueler than aknife in the head, but it is certainly faster and easier and not everyone likes to knife a live lobster in the head (after he's dead of course, few have any problems with this). He has beenknow tothrow them in the pot alive, and assures me that the (very creepy) whistling sound you sometimes hear is the air escaping from the shell - lobsters have no vocal chords of course.
My philosophy, as with crabs, is that if I were bobbing in the ocean they would just as happily eat me. ;-)
From far inland...The last time I saw lobster being prepared on tele, the chef did just what you're doing here. The guy with him said, "Wait. What? Why didn't you just toss him in the pot of boiling water?"The dude was the fisherman who pulled the lobster with his pots. So...in your experience, do most people nowadays do this before putting in the pot? I was always told they die instantly anyway (again, I'm talking crawdaddies which are fresh-water, mini lobsters-ish).Curious!
Posted by: mad-tante | 07/20/2009 at 07:48 AM
So.very.jealous. It's been ages since I've enjoyed one of these. Can you believe people used to throw them away because they considered them waste?
Posted by: electric firefly | 07/20/2009 at 11:21 AM
[this is good] Hilarious! However, I am insanely jealous. Can I come to dinner tomorrow? LOL
Posted by: Yvette Ivy | 07/20/2009 at 12:09 PM
Well, it's the Mister who does all the cooking and he says that boiling them may be a little crueler than aknife in the head, but it is certainly faster and easier and not everyone likes to knife a live lobster in the head (after he's dead of course, few have any problems with this). He has beenknow tothrow them in the pot alive, and assures me that the (very creepy) whistling sound you sometimes hear is the air escaping from the shell - lobsters have no vocal chords of course.
My philosophy, as with crabs, is that if I were bobbing in the ocean they would just as happily eat me. ;-)
Posted by: karen | 07/20/2009 at 12:49 PM
No, I can't believe that at all. They are way too delicious to be anything but dinner...or lunch...even breakfast works for me.
Posted by: karen | 07/20/2009 at 12:50 PM
Now see, tomorrow would be much too late. There won't even be leftovers tomorrow!
;-)
Posted by: karen | 07/20/2009 at 12:50 PM
Sweet jesus, even though Xav did that once at our house that picture has my jaw on the desk!
Should've used a bigger knife.
Posted by: Cathy | 07/20/2009 at 02:13 PM
I like your philosophy!I didn't know if there was "new thinking" or personal preference. :)
Posted by: mad-tante | 07/21/2009 at 04:39 AM